Best Big Cartel Alternatives in 2026

The main Big Cartel alternatives are Shopify when your shop is growing, Etsy to be found by buyers already shopping for handmade work, Ecwid for a cheap shop inside another site, Square Online for a free store that matches your market stall, and Squarespace for a portfolio-style shop.

Big Cartel's plans today, and when to move on

Big Cartel's pricing page on November 10, 2026 showed a free Gold plan with limited features, Platinum at $15 a month after a 7-day trial, and Diamond at $30 a month, which adds abandoned cart recovery, scheduled drops and Zapier.

The usual reasons to leave are wanting more apps, more themes or a larger catalogue. Shopify Basic is $19 a month billed yearly. Squarespace Core at $17 billed yearly suits artists who also want a portfolio and blog. WooCommerce is free as a plugin, but hosting usually costs $25 to $350 a month.

Sources: Big Cartel pricing; Shopify pricing; Squarespace pricing; WooCommerce pricing.

Big Cartel is made for artists and makers: a free Gold plan, then Platinum at $15 a month and Diamond at $30 (November 3, 2026). People leave when they want more design freedom, more apps, or more buyers than their own audience brings. The options below are the ones makers usually weigh, from a marketplace to a full store.

The best Big Cartel alternatives

Shopify

Full hosted store with themes, apps and point of sale.

Best for: Makers turning a side shop into a business

Pricing: Basic $19/mo billed yearly ($25 monthly); Grow $49/mo billed yearly ($65 monthly)

Pros: Room to grow; Apps for print-on-demand and pre-orders; Sells at markets too with a card reader

Cons: Costs more than Big Cartel; Apps add monthly fees; More to learn

Etsy

Marketplace where buyers come looking for handmade and vintage goods.

Best for: Makers who need buyers more than a website

Pricing: No monthly fee; listing and transaction fees on each sale (see etsy.com/legal/fees)

Pros: Buyers already searching; No monthly fee; Quick to list

Cons: Fees on every sale; You compete with other sellers on the same page; Less control of your brand

Ecwid

Store you can embed in an existing website or social page.

Best for: Artists who already have a portfolio site

Pricing: Starter $5/mo (10 products); Venture $29/mo billed yearly ($35 monthly), 100 products; no Ecwid transaction fee

Pros: Cheap Starter plan; Works inside your current site; No Ecwid sales fee

Cons: No free plan any more; Starter caps you at 10 products; Design depends on the host site

Square Online

Online store tied to Square's card readers and stock.

Best for: Makers who sell at markets and fairs

Pricing: Free plan (card processing fees per sale); Plus and Premium add shipping and design features

Pros: Free plan; Same stock online and at fairs; Pickup options

Cons: Card fees per sale; Fewer themes; Best inside Square

Squarespace

Website builder with polished templates and a built-in store.

Best for: Artists whose work needs a gallery-quality site

Pricing: Basic $12/mo billed yearly with a 2% sales fee; Core $17/mo with 0% on store sales

Pros: Beautiful portfolio layouts; Blog and shop together; No sales fee on Core

Cons: No free plan; 2% sales fee on Basic; Fewer store apps

Prices come from each vendor's public pricing page and are not individually dated, so they may have changed. Confirm on the vendor's site before you buy.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Big Cartel?

Shopify if your shop is growing, Etsy if you need buyers who are already shopping, Ecwid to add a shop to a site you have, Square Online if you also sell at markets, and Squarespace for a gallery-style shop. Big Cartel is still one of the cheapest and simplest options for a small range.

Is there a free alternative to Big Cartel?

Square Online has a free plan and Etsy has no monthly fee (you pay per listing and per sale). Big Cartel's own Gold plan is free. Shopify and Squarespace offer trials, and Ecwid starts at $5 a month.

Can I move from Big Cartel to an alternative?

Yes. Export your products and orders from Big Cartel as CSV files, then import products into the new store or re-list them. Reconnect your domain, rebuild shipping and discount settings, and add redirects from old product links where the new platform allows it. On Etsy you list items again, since it is a marketplace rather than your own site.

Other alternatives round-ups

Related reading

More in Alternatives

Build your own site

More on this topic

How we research, test and update this page: our editorial policy. We.Inc is our own product.

Product

Who It's For

Features

Resources

Company

View Sitemap