We.Inc vs Big Cartel

Big Cartel is a shop builder made for artists and makers. We.Inc builds a whole website from a chat, with a lighter store inside it. This page helps you decide whether you need a shop with a site, or a site with a shop.

Build your site free. No card needed.

Is Big Cartel or We.Inc the better home for an independent maker?

Big Cartel is a hosted store platform aimed at independent artists and small creative brands. Its pricing page lists a free Gold plan with limited features, Platinum at $15 a month after a 7-day trial, and Diamond at $30 a month with no commitment. Every paid shop gets custom domains, physical and digital products, shipping labels with tracking, print-on-demand apps, card, PayPal and Afterpay checkout, in-person selling and a mobile app.

We.Inc starts from the website rather than the till. You describe the business in a chat, the AI builds an editable React and TypeScript site, and you keep shaping it by clicking on the page, asking in chat or opening the code editor. Selling happens in the Store panel, which connects your own Stripe account and covers variants, digital downloads, shipping rates, discount codes and an orders list.

Short answer: if the shop is the whole point and you want discounted shipping labels, print-on-demand and Afterpay without thinking about design, Big Cartel is the tidier tool. If you want a portfolio, a blog, a booking form and a small shop living together on one custom-built site, We.Inc fits better.

Where a Big Cartel shop and a We.Inc site part ways

  • Shipping: Big Cartel advertises unlimited label printing with up to 90% off shipping on both paid plans. We.Inc lets you set shipping rates in the Store panel but does not print labels.
  • Checkout methods: Big Cartel accepts cards, PayPal and Afterpay. We.Inc's store takes payments through the Stripe account you connect.
  • Design: Big Cartel shops are customised from its own themes and shop designer. A We.Inc site is generated from your description and can be changed down to the code.
  • Beyond the store: We.Inc adds a CMS for posts and listings, contact forms that feed a Contacts list, an SEO panel and built-in visitor analytics. Big Cartel's plan list centres on selling tools.
  • Drops and automation: Big Cartel Diamond includes scheduled product drops, password-protected products, abandoned cart recovery and Zapier links to 7,000+ apps. These are not listed We.Inc store features.

Feature-by-feature comparison

See exactly what you get with each platform.

FeatureWe.IncBig Cartel
Physical and digital productsYesYes
Product variantsYesYes
Discount codesYesYes
Scheduled product dropsNoDiamond plan
Payment optionsYour own StripeCards, PayPal, Afterpay
Discounted shipping labelsNoUp to 90% off
Blog and content collectionsBuilt-in CMSNot listed on plans
Edit the underlying codeBuilt-in code editorTheme customisation
Built-in visitor analyticsAnalytics panelOrder and visitor stats
Custom domainFrom Starter ($20/mo)Paid plans
Download the site's codeZIP on any planNo

Pricing

We.Inc: Free to build, no card needed. Big Cartel: Free Gold plan; Platinum $15/mo; Diamond $30/mo.

Big Cartel prices as of October 2026, from its own pricing page (linked in the sources below). Big Cartel bills monthly: Platinum is $15 a month after a 7-day free trial and Diamond is $30 a month, cancellable any time. The free Gold plan exists but its limits are not spelled out on the pricing page. The page shows an annual toggle without annual amounts, and it does not list transaction fees, so payment costs depend on the processor you use. Prices as of October 2026.

Illustrators, bands and print shops versus businesses that also sell

Big Cartel is built around the rhythm of a creative seller: a run of prints, a tour merch batch, a zine restock. Cheap labels, print-on-demand apps, product drops on Diamond and Afterpay at checkout all serve someone whose site is basically a product grid. The design side stays simple on purpose.

We.Inc suits a person whose business is wider than the shop. A tattoo artist who wants a portfolio, a booking enquiry form and a few prints for sale, or a photographer with client galleries and a small print store, gets those pages built from one description. Products sit in the Store panel and blog entries in the CMS, which you edit without spending AI credits.

Pick Big Cartel when shipping and drops matter most

If you post dozens of parcels a week, the shipping label discounts alone may decide it, since We.Inc has no label printing. The same goes for timed releases, password-locked products for fan clubs, Afterpay, or selling face to face from the Big Cartel app. At $15 a month Platinum is also cheaper than We.Inc's $20 Starter plan when all you need is a shop.

Taking your Big Cartel shop over to We.Inc

Big Cartel's help centre explains how to download order data: open Orders, choose a tab such as All Orders or tick specific orders, and click Export orders to get a CSV. Its help pages cover importing products with a template but we found no product export article, so keep your own copy of product titles, prices and photos before you leave.

Then paste your shop's address into We.Inc and ask it to rebuild the site. You get an editable version with the same structure and content to refine. Add products in the Store panel and connect Stripe. Customer accounts, order history and any Big Cartel apps do not transfer, so archive the CSV.

If your shop runs on your own domain, connect it on Starter or above with the single CNAME record shown in the Domain panel, and HTTPS is issued automatically. Ask the AI to keep familiar paths such as /products and /contact so links in your social bios still land somewhere.

Frequently asked questions

How much does Big Cartel cost in 2026?

Big Cartel's pricing page lists three plans. Gold is free with limited features, Platinum costs $15 a month after a 7-day free trial, and Diamond costs $30 a month with no commitment. Diamond adds abandoned cart recovery, scheduled drops, password-protected products, Zapier connections and priority support. Card and PayPal processing fees are charged by the payment provider, separately from the plan.

Can We.Inc print shipping labels like Big Cartel?

No. We.Inc's Store panel lets you set shipping rates that customers see at checkout, and lists orders for you to fulfil, but label printing is not one of its features. Big Cartel includes label printing with tracking on its paid plans and advertises up to 90% off shipping, which matters if you send a lot of parcels.

Is We.Inc a good fit for an artist portfolio with a shop?

It is a reasonable fit. You describe the portfolio, the pages you want and the products, and the AI builds the site; you then edit by clicking, chatting or in code. The Store panel handles prints or downloads through your own Stripe account, and the CMS keeps project pages or posts editable without AI credits.

Can I keep my Big Cartel domain if I switch?

Yes, if you own the domain. On We.Inc's Starter plan or above, add it in the Domain panel and create the one CNAME record it shows at your registrar; the HTTPS certificate is issued automatically. Keep your main page paths the same so older links keep working after the move.

Verdict

Big Cartel is the cheaper, more focused choice for makers whose site is mostly a shop, especially with heavy shipping or timed drops. We.Inc is worth the extra $5 a month at Starter when you want a fuller site, with a portfolio, blog, forms and analytics, built from a chat and selling through your own Stripe.

Sources

Facts checked October 17, 2026.

More We.Inc comparisons

Related reading

More in Compare

Build your own site

More on this topic

How we research, test and update this page: our editorial policy. We.Inc is our own product.

Ready to build yours? Build your site free. No card needed.

Product

Who It's For

Features

Resources

Company

View Sitemap