We.Inc vs Sellfy

Sellfy is a storefront for creators selling digital files, memberships and print-on-demand merch. We.Inc builds a full website from a chat, with downloads sold through your own Stripe. This page shows where each one earns its fee.

Build your site free. No card needed.

What does Sellfy do that We.Inc does not, and the other way round?

Sellfy is a hosted store for creators. Its pricing page lists Starter at $22 a month billed yearly, Business at $59 and Premium at $119, with monthly billing at $29, $79 and $159. Each plan carries an annual sales limit of $10K, $50K and $200K, and Sellfy takes a 0% transaction fee. All plans include unlimited products, downloads, subscriptions, merch, email marketing, PayPal and Stripe, custom domains and coupon codes.

We.Inc treats the store as one part of a bigger site. Describe your work in chat and it builds an editable React and TypeScript site that you change by clicking, chatting or in a code editor. The Store panel connects your Stripe account for products with variants, digital downloads, shipping rates, discount codes and orders, and a CMS keeps posts and listings editable without AI credits.

In short: a creator who mainly sells files, memberships and merch, and wants email marketing, upsells and an affiliate program in the same dashboard, is better served by Sellfy. Someone who needs a proper site around a few products, with pages, forms and a blog, gets more from We.Inc.

Sellfy and We.Inc compared on what creators actually sell

  • Revenue caps: Sellfy plans stop at $10K, $50K or $200K of yearly sales and may charge a 2% overage above the cap if you do not upgrade. We.Inc plans are priced by AI credits, not by what you sell.
  • Memberships: Sellfy includes subscription products on every plan. Subscriptions are not part of We.Inc's listed store features.
  • Merch: Sellfy sells print-on-demand merch alongside downloads. We.Inc's Store panel handles physical products with shipping rates but does not list print-on-demand.
  • Marketing: Sellfy bundles email marketing with 2,000 to 50,000 credits by plan, plus upsells, cart abandonment and affiliates from Business up. We.Inc has an SEO panel, analytics and contact forms rather than email campaigns.
  • The site: We.Inc builds whatever pages you describe and lets you edit the code. Sellfy offers a store editor and themes focused on the storefront.

Feature-by-feature comparison

See exactly what you get with each platform.

FeatureWe.IncSellfy
Digital downloadsYesUp to 10 to 20GB per file
Subscriptions and membershipsNoAll plans
Print-on-demand merchNoAll plans
Platform transaction feeNone; your Stripe0%
ProcessorsStripePayPal and Stripe
Email marketingNo2,000 to 50,000 credits
Discount codesYesYes
Affiliate programNoBusiness and Premium
Pages beyond the storeAny page you describeStore editor and themes
SEO panel with sitemapYesNot listed on plans
Download the site codeZIP on any planNo

Pricing

We.Inc: Free to build, no card needed. Sellfy: Starter $22/mo, Business $59/mo, Premium $119/mo (yearly).

Sellfy prices as of October 2026, from its own pricing page (linked in the sources below). Sellfy bills monthly at $29, $79 or $159, or saves 25% on yearly billing at $22, $59 or $119 a month. Each plan has an annual sales limit of $10K, $50K or $200K; past it you are expected to upgrade or may pay a 2% overage. Sellfy charges no transaction fee, but PayPal or Stripe fees still apply. Prices as of October 2026.

Course makers and designers on Sellfy, service brands on We.Inc

Sellfy is shaped around a creator whose income is the product list: preset packs, beats, fonts, ebooks, a monthly membership and a merch line. The built-in email tool, upsells and affiliates let that creator grow revenue without adding other services, and the 10GB to 20GB file limits suit video and audio.

We.Inc suits a creator whose site does more than sell. A designer with case studies, a contact form for commissions and a couple of paid templates, or a coach with a blog and a downloadable workbook, gets those pages from one description. Downloads go through the Store panel and enquiries into the Contacts list.

Stay with Sellfy if subscriptions or email drive your income

Sellfy is the better pick if recurring memberships, print-on-demand merch, an affiliate program or built-in email campaigns are central to how you earn. We.Inc does not list those features, and adding them yourself would mean wiring in other services. Sellfy's revenue caps are the trade-off to watch as you grow.

Shifting a Sellfy shop to a We.Inc site

Sellfy's help centre has an article on exporting order data, which lists product, order number, status, date, payer email and totals in a file you can open in a spreadsheet. Its email marketing article describes exporting buyer and subscriber lists from Marketing as CSV files. Download both before you cancel, and keep your original product files.

Then paste your Sellfy store address into We.Inc and ask it to rebuild the site, which gives you an editable starting version with the same structure and content. Upload your downloads in the Store panel and connect Stripe. Active Sellfy subscriptions do not move, so plan how existing members will be billed.

If you used a custom domain, connect it on Starter or above with the one CNAME record from the Domain panel; HTTPS is issued automatically. Keep the main page paths the same so links in your newsletter and social bios still work.

Frequently asked questions

Does Sellfy take a cut of each sale?

Sellfy's pricing page lists a 0% Sellfy transaction fee on all three plans. PayPal or Stripe still charge their own processing fees, which Sellfy describes as typically 2.9% plus 30 cents. The catch is the annual sales limit on each plan; above it you upgrade, or Sellfy may charge 2% on the extra revenue.

Can I sell digital downloads on We.Inc?

Yes. Digital downloads are one of the We.Inc Store panel's listed features, alongside products with variants, shipping rates, discount codes and an orders list. Payments go to the Stripe account you connect. Memberships and recurring billing are not listed, so a subscription-based creator should weigh that.

What happens to my Sellfy email list if I move?

Sellfy lets you export buyer and newsletter subscriber lists as CSV files from its Marketing area, according to its help centre. Download those before you cancel. We.Inc does not include email campaigns, so you would load the list into a separate email service and add its signup form to your new site.

Which costs less for a creator just starting out?

We.Inc Starter is $20 a month with 250 AI credits and a custom domain. Sellfy Starter is $22 a month billed yearly or $29 monthly, capped at $10K of sales a year. Neither charges its own transaction fee. The better value depends on whether you need Sellfy's email and subscription tools.

Verdict

Sellfy is the stronger all-in-one for creators whose business is files, memberships and merch, backed by built-in email and affiliates. We.Inc is the better fit when you want a full, editable site with a simple Stripe store for downloads and no sales cap on your plan.

Sources

Facts checked October 17, 2026.

More We.Inc comparisons

Related reading

More in Compare

Build your own site

How we research, test and update this page: our editorial policy. We.Inc is our own product.

Ready to build yours? Build your site free. No card needed.

Product

Who It's For

Features

Resources

Company

View Sitemap