We.Inc vs Substack

Substack is a publishing network where writers send newsletters and charge for subscriptions, paying a share of revenue rather than a monthly fee. We.Inc builds a full website from a chat. This page helps writers decide whether they need a platform, a site, or both.

Build your site free. No card needed.

A paid newsletter network versus a website of your own

Substack describes itself as a platform for writers, creators and media companies to earn money from their work. It is free to start, with no platform fees, tiers or contracts. When you turn on paid subscriptions, writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees. You choose which posts are free and which are for paying subscribers, and Substack's own pages stress that you own your content and your subscriber list. It also runs a reader app and discovery pages that can bring new readers.

We.Inc builds a website instead of hosting you inside a network. You describe the site in chat, it creates an editable React and TypeScript project, and a CMS panel holds blog posts and other collections that you edit without AI credits. Other panels add a Stripe store, contact forms, an SEO panel, analytics and a Cloud panel with user logins.

If your goal is to publish, grow an email audience and charge readers with no upfront cost, Substack is the simpler start. If the writing supports a business with services, products or bookings, a We.Inc site gives you a home that Substack's publication pages are not designed to be.

What a writer gives and gets on each

  • How you pay: Substack costs nothing to start and takes 10% of paid subscription revenue, plus card fees. We.Inc charges a flat plan, from $20 a month for AI building, and takes no share of what you earn.
  • Newsletters and paywalls: Substack sends every post by email and lets you mark posts as paid-only. We.Inc does not include newsletter sending or paid memberships; its forms can pass sign-ups to an email tool through a webhook.
  • Discovery: Substack has a reader app and topic leaderboards where readers find new publications. A We.Inc site relies on search, its SEO panel and your own promotion.
  • Site scope: a Substack publication is posts, archive and subscription pages. We.Inc builds whatever pages the business needs, plus a store, forms feeding a Contacts list, and app features through the Cloud panel.
  • Design: Substack publications share its layout system. We.Inc generates a custom design and lets you edit it by click, chat or code.

Feature-by-feature comparison

See exactly what you get with each platform.

FeatureWe.IncSubstack
Email newsletter deliveryNoYes
Paid subscriptionsNoWriters keep 90%
Blog posts on the webCMS panelYes
Built-in reader discoveryNoReader app and topic pages
Cost to startFree to build, no card neededFree
Share of revenue takenNone; Stripe fees on store sales10% plus card fees
Custom-designed pagesBuilt from chat, editable in codeSubstack layouts
Store for products and downloadsStore panel with your StripeNo
Contact forms and lead listContacts listNo
Per-page SEO controlsSEO panelNot confirmed

Pricing

We.Inc: Free to build, no card needed. Substack: Free to start; 10% of paid subscription revenue plus card fees.

Substack prices as of October 2026, from its own pricing page (linked in the sources below). Substack does not charge a subscription. Its pages say it is free to start with no platform fees, tiers or contracts, and that writers keep 90% of paid subscription revenue minus credit card fees. The cost therefore grows with your income: at $5,000 a month in paid subscriptions, Substack's share would be $500 before card fees. We.Inc's AI plans are flat, from $20 a month.

Full-time newsletter writers, and businesses that publish

Substack fits a writer whose readers are the product: an analyst, journalist, essayist or podcaster who wants to start free, find readers through Substack's network and later charge for some posts. There is no bill until money comes in, and the platform takes care of payments and email delivery.

We.Inc fits someone for whom writing is marketing for something else: a consultant, therapist, designer or shop owner. They need service pages, an enquiry form that lands in a Contacts list, maybe a small Stripe store, and a blog in the CMS. A flat plan also makes sense once 10% of paid subscription revenue would cost more than a site.

Stay on Substack while the audience is the business

If you are building a paid newsletter, Substack gives you email delivery, paywalls, payments and discovery for no upfront cost, and We.Inc offers none of those as built-in features. Many writers keep Substack for the letter and add a separate site only once there is something besides the newsletter to sell.

Building a We.Inc site around, or instead of, your Substack

Substack's pages say you own all of your content and your subscriber list. We could not open Substack's help article on exporting, which was behind a security check, so follow its help center for the current steps to download posts and your subscriber list before you move anything.

In We.Inc, paste the URL of your publication and ask for a rebuild to get the layout and recent posts as an editable starting point, then keep articles in a CMS collection. Paid subscriptions and email sending have no direct equivalent, so either keep Substack for the newsletter and link to it from the site, or move subscribers to a dedicated email service.

If your publication used a custom domain, connect it to We.Inc with the CNAME record from the Domain panel (Starter and up), and ask the AI to keep post addresses the same so old links still open.

Frequently asked questions

How much does Substack charge?

Substack is free to start, and its pages say there are no platform fees, tiers or contracts. If you enable paid subscriptions, writers keep 90% of revenue minus credit card fees, so Substack's share is 10%. Free newsletters cost nothing. The more paid subscribers you have, the more Substack earns from your publication.

Can We.Inc send my newsletter instead of Substack?

No. Newsletter sending is not part of We.Inc's features. A We.Inc form can collect email sign-ups and pass them to your own endpoint, a Zapier or Make webhook, or a CRM, and you would send the newsletter from a separate email service. Substack does both collecting and sending in one place.

When is a flat-priced site cheaper than Substack?

Roughly when 10% of your paid subscription revenue exceeds your site and email tool costs. We.Inc Starter is $20 a month, so on revenue alone the break-even sits near $200 a month, but you would also pay an email service and handle paywalls yourself. For most writers, Substack stays cheaper until subscriptions are substantial.

Can I keep Substack and use a We.Inc site too?

Yes. A common setup is a We.Inc site on your main domain for services, products and an about page, with a menu link or button to your Substack sign-up. That costs a We.Inc plan on top of Substack's revenue share, so it makes sense when the site does a job the newsletter cannot.

Verdict

Substack is the better start for a writer building a paid or free newsletter audience, since it costs nothing upfront and handles email, paywalls and discovery. We.Inc is the better home when the writing supports a business that needs real pages, a store or forms, at a flat price with no revenue share.

Sources

Facts checked October 17, 2026.

More We.Inc comparisons

Related reading

More in Compare

Build your own site

How we research, test and update this page: our editorial policy. We.Inc is our own product.

Ready to build yours? Build your site free. No card needed.

Product

Who It's For

Features

Resources

Company

View Sitemap